She didn’t want to say she was sick.
Hillary Clinton, that is, who recently has suffered coughing fits followed Sunday by a
near-collapse during New York’s 9/11 memorial ceremony.
She left the ceremony early, claiming overheatedness, and appeared to
weave, lose her footing and pitch forward as she approached her car, as
captured on a cellphone video.
Later in the day, Clinton’s campaign announced that the Democratic candidate has pneumonia.
Most by now are familiar with the fallout — speculation about her health, concerns about her transparency in
not reporting her illness sooner
— all amid the furor over Clinton’s weird comment at a fundraiser about
half of Donald Trump’s followers belonging in a “basket of
deplorables.”
Say what?
Other than being one of the strangest combinations of words ever uttered, where did Clinton come up with such verbiage?
Here’s the partial quote in question:
“You know, to just be grossly generalistic, you could put half of
Trump’s supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables. Right?
The racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamophobic — you name it.”
Since
when does she like to use such words, which don’t sound at all like
Clinton? She’s too studied and cautious to randomly toss out a phrase
that, in addition to being offensive and inevitably problematic, has a
somewhat poetic edge.
A-tisket, a-tasket, are those deplorables in your basket?
Perhaps
the phrase, certain to become a campaign metaphor for “uh-oh,” evolved
during a brainstorming session with folks who wouldn’t dare censor their
boss:
Basket of deplorables, hilarious! OMG, you should use that!
Clinton’s
basket may as well have been delivered to Trump with a bottle of
champagne and a bow. As she began apologizing for speaking too broadly
about too many Americans — suffering the inevitable comparison to
Mitt Romney’s “47 percent” — Trump glided along the unfamiliar terrain of the high road.
Rather than harp on the already popular trope that Clinton isn’t physically strong enough to be president,
he said he hopes she recovers soon
so that they can meet in debate. About this, Trump didn’t have to feign
sincerity, figuring he’d have a better shot at defeating Clinton than
he would Joe Biden, Tim Kaine or some other sudden substitute. But
mainly, he calculated — or had been instructed — that attacking a woman
when she was literally down would get him nowhere.
Then again,
it’s hardly necessary to point out Clinton’s physical frailties,
temporary though they are, when the woman is so plainly suffering.
Replay after replay shows the coughing fit and then the weave-and-bob of
her 9/11 episode. Anchors and commentators hit auto-pundit to produce
the question du jour: Can this woman handle the presidency? Please. This
woman has a bad cold. She needs rest. She’ll be fine.
Another question also arose, at least in many women’s minds: Would
anyone ask the same question about a man under similar circumstances?
Here’s the more pertinent question: Why do women feel they can’t admit
to being sick? You know the answer. It’s because women fear showing any
sign of weakness lest others presume the worst — that she’s not as good
as a man
As the weaker sex, which is only true as concerns upper-body muscle mass (
about 40 percent less)
and significantly less testosterone (hence less invading, marauding and
pillaging), women tend to hide anything that might suggest “weaker
sex.” This is absurd on its face, but it also happens to be true.
Thus,
Clinton soldiered on,
trying to keep to schedule despite probably feeling awful, and paid a
high price for denial. Her silence about the pneumonia wasn’t so much a
lack of transparency, as news-gazers have extrapolated, as it was a
valiant attempt to stay the course and preclude exactly what happened.
People began to wonder about her health. Critics found it easy to
conclude: She’s weak; she’s frail; she’s a woman, after all.
When
did it become a liability to be sick, which all of us are from time to
time? For women, it began when they entered the male-dominated workplace
en masse a generation ago and worked twice as hard to be as good as a
man. This likely is why Clinton would rather suffer in silence than
endure further scrutiny about her ability to serve — a deplorable
reality deserving of its own basket.
{
via}
The Fix: Why CAnother question also arose, at least in many women’s minds: Would
anyone ask the same question about a man under similar circumstances?
Here’s the more pertinent question: Why do women feel they can’t admit
to being sick? You know the answer. It’s because women fear showing any
sign of weakness lest others presume the worst — that she’s not as good
as a man. linton’s health incident isn’t going away
Embed
Share
Play Video2:
The Fix's Aaron Blake explains the incident
during which Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton fell ill on
Sept. 11, and why her health is likely to remain a subject of
discussion.
(Peter Stevenson/The Washington Post)